BofA Securities raised its price target on Klarna (NYSE:KLAR) to $20 from $19 and kept its Buy rating, pointing to third-quarter results that came in ahead of its own estimates and the Street consensus. Transaction margin dollars rose 32.0% year-over-year to $371 million, above BofA's $360 million estimate and the consensus of $355 million. Gross merchandise volume reached $36.1 billion, up 10.3%, beating estimates of $35.6 billion and $35.7 billion.

The earnings line is where the story gets more interesting. Adjusted operating income came in at $21 million, against BofA's estimate of $9 million and the Street's $8 million, a 2.1% margin. Revenue totaled $1,009 million versus estimates of $976 million and $966 million. Those are strong numbers on the top line and the operating line, and they deserve credit.

Still, the report leaves unresolved questions that investors should weigh before treating this as a turnaround. Management left fiscal 2026 guidance unchanged even though it forgoes a $30 million transaction margin dollar benefit from an accounting change. Klarna's adjusted earnings per share also showed a loss of $0.19, larger than the anticipated loss of $0.15. Morgan Stanley cut its price target from $17 to $14 with an Equalweight rating, citing the removal of roughly $30 million from the second half's transaction margin dollar pull-forward as Klarna stops expecting enough U.S. and German Fair Financing sales to trigger fair value presentation.

Those two views can both be right. The quarter was better than expected on volume, revenue and operating income, yet the per-share loss widened and the stock, at $14.27, is down more than 50% year-to-date. A higher target from BofA and a lower one from Morgan Stanley suggest analysts disagree about how much of the growth is durable and how much depends on accounting timing.

My conclusion is that Klarna has earned a hearing but not yet a verdict. The next test is whether the company can convert its volume growth into consistent adjusted profitability without leaning on accounting changes. Investors should look for fourth-quarter transaction margin dollars near the $434 million BofA projects, and for guidance that holds up without accounting help.