Reddit told Australia's High Court on Monday that the country's teen social media ban is "ill thought out" and "inept." Perry Herzfeld, a lawyer for Reddit, said the law amounts to "a very profound restriction on political debate in Australia." Reddit and a libertarian advocacy group brought the case, the first legal challenge to the law.

Herzfeld argued that barring under-16s from holding accounts stops them from creating or responding to content on what he called "the most important means of communication in the modern world." He said Reddit supports the law's aim of minimizing harm to minors, but he argued the law does not achieve that aim. He said the legislation does not set a specific measure to keep out minors and does not cover other online services where cyberbullying occurs, such as gaming websites.

Herzfeld also said that vast amounts of social media material are visible to people without accounts. "If the Commonwealth is worried about particular features (of social media), it should regulate the features, which it has not done," he said.

The Australian government and its communications minister, a named defendant, have said they will defend the law. Multiple studies, including one by the eSafety Commissioner, have found that most teenagers under the age limit still use social media. The government has since doubled the maximum fine for non-compliance to A$99 million ($69.5 million), given the eSafety Commissioner greater discovery powers, and said it is preparing an enforcement lawsuit against some of the largest platforms.